Bentley Communities
Site
Search
User
Site
Search
User
Product Communities
RAM | STAAD | ADINA
RAM | STAAD Forum
Bending Moment diagram for response spectrum loading
Sign In
Replies
2 replies
Subscribers
111 subscribers
Views
5428 views
Users
0 members are here
Seismic loading
Bending Moment diagram for response spectrum loading
Ambrish
over 15 years ago
A portal frame was analysed by equivalent Static load and Response spectrum method. My doubt is that a. The Bending moment diagram for the static load method is different from that of the response spectrum method. Why is it so? b. Is there any error in my application of response spectrum load, if so, how it is to be corrected. I request your kind attention on the above issue please, awaiting your kind replies urgently.”
Parents
NIHESH.N
Sat, Apr 25 2009 4:48 PM
Please go through the attached word file. I hope this helps.
Negative value of Force at member end in a Response Spectrum Analysis.zip
Cancel
Vote Up
0
Vote Down
Sign in to reply
Cancel
Reply
NIHESH.N
Sat, Apr 25 2009 4:48 PM
Please go through the attached word file. I hope this helps.
Negative value of Force at member end in a Response Spectrum Analysis.zip
Cancel
Vote Up
0
Vote Down
Sign in to reply
Cancel
Children
Ambrish
Wed, Apr 29 2009 10:01 AM
in reply to
NIHESH.N
Thank you very much Mr. Nihesh Response spectrum analysis gives absolute values of forces and moments. that is ok. The BMD for response spectrum case does not change the sign at the midspan of beam as all the values are positive. Thus, beam and column support moments are obtained correctly by using + and - sign in load combinations but the values at midspan of beams can not be directly used in design as it is also getting added and subtracted. In reality, for lateral load case, the midspan moment in beams is nearly zero. How to take care of this during the combination of loads, to obtain actual span moments. awaiting your reply with warmest regards Ambrish
Cancel
Vote Up
0
Vote Down
Sign in to reply
Cancel