Underground RCC tank - Structural Analysis and Design - Forum - Structural Analysis and Design - Bentley Communities

Underground RCC tank

Structural Analysis and Design

Structural Analysis and Design
This is where you can find and contribute to discussions, ideas, and other information about Bentley Structural Analysis and Design products.
Structural Analysis and Design - Forum

Underground RCC tank

  • brine tanks.std

    Hi all,

    i have to design an underground RCC 4 chamber tank, for that i have modelled it with plates = 350mm as per IS 3370.

    I was comparing the results of manual calculations with staad. they are not maching.

    Staad shows maximum moment at the centre (two way bulging, thats ok because the ratio = 1), but the moment works out to be maximum of 17Kn.m as per staad while it comes out about 37Kn.m manually.

    Second thing i also want to know whether the suppoerts modelled are correct, as the soil is silty sand with SBC  = 150 Kn/m2.

    Please suggest necessay corrections, technically as well as in modeeling.

    Thanks in advance. 

  • Hi , I think that 15000 could be wright, this constant depends also on the geometry and dimension of the fundation, I dont Know If you use the expresion K BxB = K0,3 ((B + 0.3)/(2B))2 ;(Terzaghi, the expresion for square foundation in metric units)  where B is the distance between the walls,  (B = 4.85 m in your case) and K0,3 is the is the value of the modulus of the soil that you obtain by field test using a 0.30 x0.30 m plate .  Finally KBXL = KBxB (1 + 0.5 B/L )/1.5 where L is the lenght of the foundation ( L = 19.40 m in your case).

    Another thing is that the number of plates to represent the behavior of the fundation is very low, ( you have 5 x 5 plates) you need at least 8 x 8 plates in each tank. a quik correction will be divide each plate in four.

    I hope this help you

    Regards

    Atilio

  • Thank you 'atilio' for sharing your views and comments.

    I think you have modified the model, can you please upload it.

  • brine tanks modifie.std
    HI avadtala I upload here the model