10 Minute time logging, ROLLING or STATIC?

So watched the video, read the PDF still not clear. Just looking at the forums here Bentley could be doing a better job at this. or just do what every other software vendor does and offer hard limited licenses. 

The way the video, and the PDF explain the 10 minutes usage its not 10 minutes. its any usage that crosses a 10 minute border.

That is:

Start at 1:01 and close at 1:09 Not counted.  8 minutes of use not counted

Start at 1:08 and close at 1:11 Counted. 3 minutes of use is counted since it crosses the 1:10 boundary. 

What would make sense is that the 10 minute boundary is dynamic and moves with the user, such that,

Start at 1:01 and close at 1:09 Not counted.  8 minutes of use not counted did not cross the 1:11 boundary

Start at 1:08 and close at 1:11 Not Counted. 3 minutes of use did not cross the 1:18 boundary

Parents Reply Children
  • Unknown said:

    This is not what is shown in your current documentation.

    https://www.bentley.com/~/asset/14/9787.ashx

    "You must use the software at least 10 minutes and for a complete interval for your initial interval to be counted."

    Note that the initial interval is not counted. This does not apply to subsequent intervals. So in your latest example, usage from 1:01:xx - 1:09:59 (i.e. the initial interval) is not counted, but the usage from 1:10:00 - 1:19:xx is.



  • Then the wording in your documentation is wrong. A usage from 1:01 to 1:19 is never for a complete interval.

    What you mean to say and what you say in your documentation are different.
  • Let us revisit the statement in the documentation again:
    "You must use the software at least 10 minutes and for a complete interval for your initial interval to be counted."

    Two conditions must be met:

    1. "You must use the software at least 10 minutes"
    2. "and for a complete interval"

    These two conditions must be met "for your initial interval to be counted." Note that it states initial, not any interval.



  • The wording could be revised. The fact you had to make a PDF and a Video to explain it is part of the problem.
  • Hi Jeremy,

    Per the "Term License Fact Sheet", "Since use for a complete 10 minute interval is required before a session is counted,the first interval is never counted." and this points to the partial interval prior to hitting the first 10-minute-marker (i.e. 1:10 in this example.)  If the "first interval" is never counted, then which "initial interval" are you referring to?  If you call the first partial interval the "initial" one, then you have a conflict in your document.  In one sentence you say that it can be counted if..., and the other sentence it says that it is never counted.

    Please also look at the statement, "You must use the software at least 10 minutes AND for a complete interval for your initial interval to be counted."  If you use the software for AT LEAST 10 minutes, then you must have passed a 10-minute-marker on the clock.  There is no way to not do 10 minutes without hitting a marker.  Therefore the "and for a complete interval" phrase does not add anything to the requirements if it refers to hitting this marker.

    Please also look at the term "complete interval".  If something is missing at the start, then it is not complete.  If something is missing at the end, then it is not complete.  The definition of complete is "having all the necessary or appropriate parts."  So if your 10 minute interval is missing any minutes, it is not complete and should not be counted.

    So, if you look at "You must use the software at least 10 minutes and for a complete interval for your initial interval to be counted." and "Since use for a complete 10 minute interval is required before a session is counted, the first interval is never counted."  The initial interval that I'm going to be charged for should be after 1) I've used the product for at least 10 minutes, and 2) I've used the product for a complete interval, from the beginning to the end.

    Again, take a look at the wording "A complete interval", "YOUR initial interval" and "ANY interval thereafter".  The "inital interval" is not "the" initial interval, it is "your" initial interval.  MY initial interval is the first interval that I am billed for. That interval should not be counted unless I use the software for at least 10 minutes, and it is a complete clock interval (from beginning to end).  After that, then each of my intervals will count, even if they are partial.

    If the document were to say that you must use the software for at least 10 minutes and you won't be billed for the time before the first 10-minute-marker, then what you are saying would make sense.  The fact is that the document says that I should not be billed if 1) I don't use the software for at least 10 minutes, AND 2) I don't use the software for a complete interval.

    --Thanks,
    --Robert

    Answer Verified By: dhawkins