Use "Cut soilids by curves" with slabs

Question

Hi 
 In v8i we've used the tool "cut solids by curves" to create penetrations in slabs, walls and structural framework. It seems it don't work any more. What tool should I use instead? I've found the "construct opening" which works for openings. But for eg. a slab recess it don't work. 
 Regards, 
 Robert

Steve Cocchi · Accepted Answer

Hi Robert, 
 That is in fact the reason... good catch! 
 The information in this wiki explains that it is in fact a defect, along with two workarounds you can use in the interim. 
 https://communities.bentley.com/products/building/building_analysis___design/w/building_analysis_and_design__wiki/41656/certain-structural-members-do-not-work-with-the-cut-solids-by-curve-tool

Subhamoy Kundu · Answer

Hi Robert, 
 I just made a small test case on one of the slab and it worked fine for me. Please go through and let me know if it helps you.

Steve Cocchi · Answer

Just to clarify the above, the "Cut Solid With Curve " tool under the Modeling ribbon > Solids tab is not the same as the "Cut Solids By Curves " tool under the AECOsim ribbon > Modify tab.

The dialog boxes are different and there is also a subtle color difference in the icon itself. FWIW, the MicroStation version is a new tool designed to work with Parametric solids, while the AECOsim version is the legacy tool from V8i. So as Robert noted, if customizing (or searching) you'll need to select the right version for use with Forms.

Use "Cut soilids by curves" with slabs

Top Replies