Bentley Communities
Bentley Communities
  • Site
  • User
  • Site
  • Search
  • User
  • Welcome
  • Products
  • Support
  • About
  • More
  • Cancel
OpenBuildings | AECOsim | Speedikon | LEGION
  • Product Communities
  • Building
  • OpenBuildings | AECOsim | Speedikon | LEGION
  • More
  • Cancel
OpenBuildings | AECOsim | Speedikon | LEGION
OpenBuildings | AECOsim | Speedikon | LEGION Wiki Certain Structural members do not work with the Cut Solids By Curve tool
    • Sign in
    • Building Design - Wiki
    • +OpenBuildings Designer
    • OpenBuildings Station Designer
    • -AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Annotation - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Architectural Design - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +ASM (Analytical Space Model)
      • +Configuration - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +DataGroup System - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Dataset and Content - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Drawing Extraction - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Drawing Views - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Electrical Annotation and Design - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Floors - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Form Modeling - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +General - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Grid Systems - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +HVAC Design - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +i-model - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Import/Export - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Installation - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Modify - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Platform Tools - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Plumbing Design - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Print/Plot - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +ProjectWise Integration - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Settings/Attributes - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Space Planner - AECOsim Building Designer
      • -Structural Design - AECOsim Building Designer
        • Calculating Structural member surface area for Fireproofing
        • Can a Slab have a Sloping Elevation Point?
        • Cannot modify the length of certain Beams
        • Certain Structural members do not work with the Cut Solids By Curve tool
        • CONNECT Edition - Modify Pipe Railing
        • Controlling the creation/display of section labels and physical member lines
        • Create an individual concrete beam or column
        • Creating a Custom Drawing Label
        • Creating custom Structural Sections in AECOsim
        • Custom Structural Elements - General Information
        • Edit handles not working on RHS Steel Section
        • How to create Mitred joint between steel beam members?
        • How to place Nodal Force in a Member?
        • ISM Repository Not Creating Properly
        • Missing Sketch Grid (Axis) in Drawing Views
        • Modifying Structural Rules and Updating Structural Members in Drawing Views
        • Moving mitred steel beams can change geometry
        • New Bar Joist Key-In
        • Place Column Pile Length
        • Place Deck Tool Generates Microsoft.NET Error
        • Place Steel Section With Twisted Angle
        • ProStructures SS7 Files do not display correctly
        • Quantification Report of Slabs in AECOsim Building Designer
        • Removing Grids Models From Structural Drawing Center
        • Reporting on PAZ cells that include Structural properties
        • Run-time error '5'; Invalid procedure call or argument
        • +Steel Members - Structural Design - AECOsim Building Designer
        • Structural Members Do Not Display Annotation in 3D Model
        • Structural members don't seem to retain their relationships to one another.
        • Structural Quantities in the DataGroup - Steel
        • Structural Synchronizer Will Not Install
        • The usAISC21.XML file standard
        • +Timber Members - Structural Design -- AECOsim Building Designer
        • Using Structural sections from different datasets
      • +User Interface
      • +Utilities - AECOsim Building Designer
      • +Workspace - AECOsim Building Designer
    • +GenerativeComponents
    • +OpenBuildings Energy Simulator
    • +Bentley Facilities
    • +Bentley Speedikon
    • +Bentley LEGION
    • +Social Distance Assessments
    • Working from home with OpenBuildings products
    • Working from home with Speedikon
    • +iModel Plugin for Revit Overview
    • +Special Interest Group (SIG) FAQs
    • +Structural Modeler_PS
    • +Configuration Explorer
    • +Legacy Products

     
     Questions about this article, topic, or product? Click here. 

    Certain Structural members do not work with the Cut Solids By Curve tool

      Product(s): AECOsim Building Designer
      Version(s): CONNECT Edition
      Environment: N/A
      Area: Structural
      Subarea: Structural Modify

    Problem

    When attempting to use the Cut Solids By Curve tool with some of the beams in my 3D model I am getting an "element not valid for tool" message, while with others it works as expected.  I've confirmed that they are all valid Structural members and were placed in CONNECT Edition, but regardless of how the cutting shape is oriented the process just won't work for these particular beams.

    Solution

    Defect 1004460 has been filed to address this issue which is specific to Structural sections composed of multiple members such as Double Angles, Double Channels, Plate Girders, etc..  In the interim, there are two workarounds available:

    1. Using the Modify Structural Attributes command, temporarily change the existing Section Name to a single member section such as Angles, I Shapes, Rectangular Shapes, etc.. 

    Generate the cut using the Cut Solids by Curve command, then change the Section Name back to the original section assembly.

    2. Use the Construct Openings tool instead of Cut Solids by Curve. Note that the cutting shape needs to be oriented so that it cuts in a downward direction and the tool will need to be used multiple times since each instance creates an opening for only one "face" of the section assembly as shown in this video:

    Click here to play this video

    • OpenBuildings
    • modify
    • AECOsim Building Designer CONNECT Edition
    • Structural
    • Share
    • History
    • More
    • Cancel
    • Steve Cocchi Created by Bentley Colleague Communities MVP Steve Cocchi
    • When: Wed, Mar 20 2019 5:12 PM
    • Steve Cocchi Last revision by Bentley Colleague Communities MVP Steve Cocchi
    • When: Wed, Mar 20 2019 5:19 PM
    • Revisions: 4
    • Comments: 0
    Recommended
    Related
    Communities
    • Home
    • Getting Started
    • Community Central
    • Products
    • Support
    • Secure File Upload
    • Feedback
    Support and Services
    • Home
    • Product Support
    • Downloads
    • Subscription Services Portal
    Training and Learning
    • Home
    • About Bentley Institute
    • My Learning History
    • Reference Books
    Social Media
    •    LinkedIn
    •    Facebook
    •    Twitter
    •    YouTube
    •    RSS Feed
    •    Email

    © 2021 Bentley Systems, Incorporated  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy |  Terms of Use  |  Cookies