This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

SewerGEMS Invert Levels Design with Diameters Same

Dear Sir,

We have a Sewer Network of more than 5000 Manholes.The Model for it is already built by me in SewerGEMS. All Flows are entered as" Flows Known" for the Manholes. All Conduits are currently selected as "User Defined Conduits". The Current SewerGEMS Model was built via ModelBuilder & the values for Diameters, Flow, Ground Elevations & Inverts were transferred from a Sewer Design Microsoft Excel Spreadsheet & Analyzed in SewerGEMS.

 Now the problem is that there was an error in the Field Survey & therefore all the Ground Elevations have changed. If I enter these Revised Ground Elevations in SewerGEMS. can it Re-Design the Conduit Start Invert, Conduit Stop Invert & the Manhole Inverts (i.e. Manhole Structure Elevation) Keeping The Diameters Same. The Conduit Diameters are to be kept same only the Inverts are to be Re-Designed.

Thanks & Regards,

Vikas Kulkarni.

Parents
  • Vikas,

    Yes, I believe you can you re-design the start invert, stop invert, & manhole inverts, while keeping the diameters the same. Here's what you need to do.

    1) In all you node elements (manholes, catch basins, outfalls, transitions, etc...) set the "design structure elevation?" property to True and enter your desired sump depth. By default this field should already be set to True, so you might just want to double check that it still is.

    2) You might also try this although I'm not sure if it will make a difference. In the properties of your conduit Make sure the "design conduit?" field is set to true and the "design start invert?" and "design stop invert?" fields are also set to true.

    3) Open the conduit catalog (Components > Conduit Catalog) and uncheck the "Available for design?" option for all the conduits. You will get some yellow user notifications about the conduits not being able to be designed because you don't have any selected for design, but if everything works out like I'm hoping then the only thing this will do is prevent the diameter, shape, and material from changing.
     
    Please let us know if that works for you.

    Regards,
    Mark

    Mark

  • Dear Mr. Pachlhofer,

    Thanks For Your Advise / Answer / Suggestion.

    I tried All Sorts of Combinations Including the ones which you have suggested today on a Small 10 Manhole Trial Test Model for Fast Computations. It does not work. I initially created a Small 10 Manhole Test Model with say X, Y, Z, etc. Ground Elevations & Computed the Model. After that I Increased All Ground Elevations by 5m to say values P, Q, R, etc. & then tried all Sorts of Permutations & Combinations. But the Conduit Inverts (Slopes) are not Designed and the Conduits stay where they are i.e. at the same position as Designed Earlier with Very Deep Manholes. Only when we Design Completely i.e. with Catalog Conduits "Available For Design" then Immediately on Compute the Conduits are Shifted Up & there Inverts (Slopes) adjusted but with changed Diameters. I think SewerGEMS Does Not Design Only the Conduit Slopes for Given Pipe Diameters. It Either Designs Completely To Perfection Including Pipe Diameters or Does Not Design it.

    With Best Regards,
    Vikas Kulkarni.
  • Hello,

    I am assuming that , you had sizes in Conduit Catalog when you had designed the project & now you have got changed ground levels.

    Then,

    1. In the physical alternatives > select conduit type as user defined so the it will take sizes which you have got from the last design.
    2. Change the ground levels with the new data.
    3. Again Compute the model> you should get the new invert levels with the same diameters. 

    Regards,

    Sushma Choure

    Bentley Technical Suppport

Reply
  • Hello,

    I am assuming that , you had sizes in Conduit Catalog when you had designed the project & now you have got changed ground levels.

    Then,

    1. In the physical alternatives > select conduit type as user defined so the it will take sizes which you have got from the last design.
    2. Change the ground levels with the new data.
    3. Again Compute the model> you should get the new invert levels with the same diameters. 

    Regards,

    Sushma Choure

    Bentley Technical Suppport

Children
  • Dear Madam (Ms. Sushma Choure),

    I have tried this - It does not work. SewerGEMS Does Not Design "User Defined Conduits". I tried this myself - In this case as I have specified above the Conduit Inverts (Slopes) are not Designed and the Conduits stay where they are i.e. at the same position as Designed Earlier with Very Deep Manholes. Only when we Design Completely i.e. Selecting as "Catalog Conduits" and with Catalog Conduits having Conduits "Available For Design" then Immediately on Compute the Conduits are Shifted Up & there Inverts (Slopes) adjusted but with changed Diameters. I think SewerGEMS Does Not Design Only the Conduit Slopes for Given Pipe Diameters. It Either Designs Completely To Perfection Including Pipe Diameters or Does Not Design it.
    SewerGEMS Does Not Design "User Defined Conduits" - Please refer the link below by some Other User of SewerGEMS :-

    communities.bentley.com/.../12666.unable-to-design-pipe-sizesinverts-when-conduit-type-set-to-user-defined

    Content of above link copy pasted below.

    Thanks & Regards,
    Vikas Kulkarni.

    Copy Pasted Link Contents:

    Unable to design pipe sizes/inverts when Conduit Type set to User Defined

    Applies To

    Product(s): Bentley SewerCAD, Bentley SewerGEMS
    Version(s): 08.11.03.77, 08.11.03.83, 08.11.03.84
    Environment: N/A
    Area: Modeling
    Subarea:
    Original Author: Scott Kampa, Bentley Technical Support Group

    Problem Description

    After computing automated design, the following user notification appears, even though I have section sizes available in the Conduit Catalog. The inverts and sizes of the conduits identified by this notification do not change.

    "Conduit Catalog should contain conduits that are available for design and with same Conduit Shape/Material. Set Design Conduit property to False, or add new conduits to Catalog."
    Steps to Resolve

    In this version of SewerCAD (or when using the GVF Convex solver in SewerGEMS) you must set your conduits to Catalog Conduits if you would like the automated design feature to attempt to design the inverts and sizes. If you have them set to User Defined, the sizes and inverts will not be changed. If needing to do this to multiple conduits, consider the below steps to global edit:

    1) Open the conduit flextable and add the Conduit Type, Section Size and Material fields if not already showing

    2) Global edit the Conduit Type field and set them all to Catalog Conduit

    3) Global edit the Material field and set them all to the appropriate material

    4) Global edit the Section Size field and set them all to an initial size. The automated design feature will adjust the size as needed, so the size you pick here does not matter.

    5) Re-compute automated design.


    Note that future versions will be enhanced so that User Defined conduits will automatically be changed to Catalog conduits.
  • Vikas,

    I know that I missed that part above where you stated the conduits were set to as "User Defined Conduits" in your first post, though I'm not sure how. I do believe that I can come up with a workaround for you. How many different (unique) diameter conduits do you have in your model?

    Regards,
    Mark

    Mark

  • Dear Mr. Mark Pachlhofer,

    The Diameters Used in the Model are as follows:

    1. H.D.P.E. - (Upto 271 mm Diameter) - Sizes - 147mm, 175mm, 217mm & 271mm
    2. Concrete - (> 271 mm Diameter) - Sizes - 300mm, 350mm, 400mm, 450mm, 500mm, 600mm, 700mm, 800mm & 900mm.

    Best Regards,
    Vikas Kulkarni.
  • I would like to clarify more - Most of it is a Repetition of what I have said earlier - There are no changes only some more clarification has been added.

    The Office Work Model is named the "Main Sewer Model" - "Section A" & for trying out various Alternatives / Permutations / Combinations I created a "Small 10 Manhole Trial Test Model" for Fast Computations. - "Section B" -

    Section A - For Main Sewer Model:

    1. The Main Model I have has had User Defined Conduits right from the beginning.
    2. This Sewer Network has @ 5000 Manholes.The Model for it is already built by me in SewerGEMS. All Flows are entered as" Flows Known" for the Manholes. All Conduits are selected as "User Defined Conduits". The Current SewerGEMS Model was built via ModelBuilder & the values for Diameters, Flow, Ground Elevations & Inverts were transferred from a Sewer Design Microsoft Excel Spreadsheet & Analyzed in SewerGEMS.
    3. Now the problem is that there was an error in the Field Survey & therefore all the Ground Elevations have changed. If I enter these Revised Ground Elevations in SewerGEMS. can it Re-Design the Conduit Start Invert, Conduit Stop Invert & the Manhole Inverts (i.e. Manhole Structure Elevation) Keeping The Diameters Same. The Conduit Diameters are to be kept same only the Inverts are to be Re-Designed.

    Now to test various Alternatives - Permutations & Combinations - I created a Small Trial Test Model of 10 Manholes.

    Section B - For Small 10 Manhole Trial Test Model:

    I tried All Sorts of Combination on a Small 10 Manhole Trial Test Model for Fast Computations. It does not work. I initially created a Small 10 Manhole Test Model with say X, Y, Z, etc. Ground Elevations & Computed it defining them as Catalog Conduits with Conduit Catalog having Conduits Available For Design in the Model & Computed It. This Computation was Perfect. SewerGEMS Designed the Conduit Diameters as well as there Slopes/ Inverts. After that I Increased All Ground Elevations by 5m to say values P, Q, R, etc. and then changed the Conduits to "User Defined" & then tried all Sorts of Permutations & Combinations. I also tried various Combinations by changing them back to Catalog Conduits with No Conduits Available for Design in the Conduit Catalog as suggested by Mr. Pachlhofer. Also tried designing Only Manhole Structural Elevations. In Short - I have tried All Possible - I really mean All Permutations & Combinations Possible -But Conduit Inverts (Slopes) are not Designed and the Conduits stay where they are i.e. at the same position as Designed Earlier with Very Deep Manholes. These Manholes appear Very Deep now because as earlier there "Rim is Set To Ground Elevation" which has been increased by 5m but in-spite of all Trials SewerGEMS does not change there Inverts since they are now"User Defined". SewerGEMS retains the diameters which were designed earlier but does not design the Slopes i.e. Inverts for "User Defined Conduits"
    Only when we Design Completely i.e. Selecting as "Catalog Conduits" and with Catalog Conduits having Conduits "Available For Design" then Immediately on Compute the Conduits are Shifted Up & there Inverts (Slopes) adjusted but with changed Diameters. I think SewerGEMS Does Not Design Only the Conduit Slopes for Given Pipe Diameters. It Either Designs Completely To Perfection Including Pipe Diameters or Does Not Design it.

    Best Regards,
    Vikas kulkarni.
  • I am waiting for more Replies to this. I would also like Mr. Jesse Dringoli to post a Reply.