There seems to be bug in Match All Elements-tool. It doens't match fill fill type. Fill type is always 'None' even if the matched element has opaque fill.
Another old bug is that it doesn't match attached element templates. As is this is not fixed for years then do not expect to get fix for this also.
(+) Match/smartmatch element templates - Drafting and Detailing - MicroStation - Bentley Communities
I tried even escalating it trough managers and supermanagers - nothing. It is one of stoppers for going to CE as without it there is no improvement over v8i and Standards checker is still unusable with wrongly assigned templates but older mdl utilities doesn't work in CE.
There are 35 votes and still considering - Add Element Templates to SmartMatch | MicroStation Ideas Portal (aha.io)