Maxsurf Structure, problem with calculating stringers, what am I doing wrong?

I'm using Maxsurf Structure Advanced 20.00.05.47.

My problem is that I can't seem to get all of the parts, mostly the stringers but also some frames, to calculate properly and produce the right shapes.

The model I'm working on is a modified version of a boat I designed using Maxsurf 15 a few years ago. The last time I was working on this design I didn't run into any issues, but I think something about the way I went about making the changes has caused my problems.

The model is a 10 m hard chine aluminium boat with integrated superstructure, my process for altering the design is as follows:

  • I opened the design in Modeller Advanced 20, and made my changes (an increase in beam from 3 to 3.5 m, change in the shape of the transom by altering a trimming surface and increasing the length of the superstructure) then saved it under a new filename.
  • Then I opened the design in Structure and defined all of my parts from a blank canvas since the design had changed enough to require different frame spacing and so on.

My problems started on calculating the new structure, it calculates everything without errors, but some of the part shapes don't make much sense:

  • The boat includes broken frames that ring webs under a floor deck (defined by a surface and plate) and open side webs above this, the frames calculate but are asymmetrical above the deck even though all the settings and dimensions are symmetrical.
  • Many of the stringers do not break correctly at the bulkheads, instead they form triangular splits on one side, or in some cases produce a part that folds back on itself as shown in the pictures below.

The shell expansion drawing also shows lots of odd spikes in the region of the superstructure around where my frames and stringers are doing odd things, so I think it is all most likely caused by the same issue with the model.

(and yes the bulkhead at the aft end of the cabin is meant to have that extra panel above deck to port)

Screenshots:

Model render with parts

Shell expansion

Lower deck stiffener

Frame 7 halfway along superstructure

(note bottom edge is different on each side)

Where is my problem coming from, thoughts?

Parents Reply
  • I've tried the shell expansion with just hull surfaces turned on, and while it looks better than when I had the other surfaces turned on it still doesn't seem to work properly.
    Also, due to design considerations I had to make other changes to this model, including moving some of the frames fore and aft. After doing that some of the frames were deleted from the model, and maxsurf won't add any to replace them (the dialogue works but it doesn't create any parts).
Children
No Data