06. Allowable longitudinal compressive Stress (σ c,all) is not calculated as per EN13445-3 Clause 16


Applies To
Product(s):AutoPIPE Vessel
Version(s):ALL
Area:General
Date Logged
& Current Version
Jan 2024
44.00.01.014

Problem:

Allowable longitudinal compressive Stress (σ c,all) is not calculated as per EN13445-3 Clause 16.14-29, Why?

Instead design stress value is taken as allowable longitudinal compressive stress. Please clarify.

Solution:

Allowable longitudinal compressive stress value shown in report is correct. 

Refer clause 16.14.8, this clause clearly says if equation 16.14-15 satisfied then design stress can be taken as allowable longitudinal compressive stress.

In this case (Operating Corroded condition), 

Mean Diameter (D) : 855.4 mm

Thickness (ea) : 34.7 mm

Modulus of elasticity (E) : 189000 MPa

Sigma e : 105.6 MPa

D/ea (24.65) ≤ 0.06 * E / Sigma e (107.38)

As equation 16.14-15 satisfied design stress value (126.7 MPa) is taken as allowable longitudinal compressive stress.

See Also

AutoPIPE Vessel

Bentley LEARN Server