For people use parametric modeling , we know that GC in Bentley products family is similar as Dynamo in Autodesk products family.
GC is primarily used in Architectural, which is the same as early version of Dynamo.
BUT dynamo is now expanding its scope to other disciplines, like dynamo for Civil 3D (linear structure, such as road, tunnel modeling), dynamo for Bridge, Dynamo for Steel structure.
I do not understand why GC has been dropped from MicroStation CONNECT, and is only available in OpenBuildings/Rail.
Being able to use GC in vanilla MicroStation to explore pure geometry is a really powerful tool for many kinds of designers who are not necessarily interested in a full blown BIM tool with all the associated overhead. Perhaps the idea is to try get the MicroStation parametric engine to take on this role, but it is no where near as flexible/creative as GC.
Dynamo's power is that it is not limited to geometry and can hook into many other area of interest in their products. With Bentley you have always had the ability to do this kind of hooking in through coding (SKD's/ VBA etc.), but this lacks the interface/immediacy/uniformity of a dynamo/GC like workflow.
Yep, GC really needs to be expanded to the Civil products like OpenRoads, OpenRail, etc.
Would be a game changer...
Regards,
Mark
OpenRoads Designer 2023 | Microstation 2023.2 | ProjectWise 2023
Hi Netsonic,
GC for as long as I have been aware of it (pre-2007) has been used in all of the use cases you mention. Whilst the entry point may have been MicroStation and now OpenBuildings Designer its has always been a versatile tool. Bentley has a large number of specialised tools for Road Rail Bridges etc and these already have a high level of parametricism based on typical activities in those disciplines that are driving, (pardon the pun) toolsets. If those toolsets are lacking in any way that an approach such as GC could meet or fulfil please share your thoughts and we can pass that onto the product management teams
Brenden Roche
Applications Engineer
Bentley Systems, Manchester UK
GC - Microstation: 2003
Grasshopper -Rhino : 2007
Dynamo - Revit : 2012
Marionette - Vectorworks : 2015
Grasshopper - ArchiCAD : 2016
GC for Aecosim : 2017
XGenerative Design - CATIA : 2019
Dynamo for Advance Steel : 2019
Dynamo for Civil 3d : 2019
Allplan?
BricsCAD?
GC - Microstation Platinum Edition : 2023?
Rhino.Inside for AutoCAD, BricsCAD, Unity and Revit (expected 2020)... assimilation from the inside?