Bentley Communities
Bentley Communities
  • Site
  • User
  • Site
  • Search
  • User
ProjectWise
  • Product Communities
ProjectWise
ProjectWise Design Integration Forum Revit integration with PW - is anybody using it?
    • Sign In

    • State Not Answered
    • Replies 6 replies
    • Subscribers 60 subscribers
    • Views 4962 views
    • Users 0 members are here
    • BIM
    • BS1192
    • ProjectWise
    • Revit

    Revit integration with PW - is anybody using it?

    Brendan McFarlane
    Offline Brendan McFarlane over 9 years ago

    If anyone has any feedback on using the Revit inegration functionality with PW, I would be glad to hear it. We are planning a large project at the moment and PW has been proposed as the collaboration platform, but as it it our first major BIM project, I am wary about committing to it without testing first on a less critial project.

    Any user experience good or bad would be useful, thanks.

    • Sign in to reply
    • Cancel
    • Paul Davis
      0 Offline Paul Davis Thu, Jun 12 2014 4:15 AM in reply to Shawn Foster

      Those that are managing Revit within PW, have you found any issues moving Revit files through the PW wrokflows (using the rules manager); am keen to understand any issues in using PW workflows, especially when access rights are assinged to various workflow states.

      Thanks

      Paul Davis

      • Cancel
      • Vote Up 0 Vote Down
      • Sign in to reply
      • Verify Answer
      • Cancel
    • Shawn Foster
      0 Offline Shawn Foster Fri, May 9 2014 9:00 AM in reply to Shawn Foster

      Oh, and we are using it as well... :)  "We" being our divisions that use Revit as we are standardized on PW for our work.

      Thanks,

      Shawn

      ------------

      • Cancel
      • Vote Up 0 Vote Down
      • Sign in to reply
      • Verify Answer
      • Cancel
    • Shawn Foster
      0 Offline Shawn Foster Fri, May 9 2014 9:00 AM in reply to Andrea Jackson

      As Paul said, read the white paper first.  Bentley originally created the PW/Revit toolset around Autodesk's own whitepaper on "Best Practices on Revit Worksharing" which is the Workset process, not Element Borrowing.

      The Workset process works very nicely because during borrow/check out is when Revit hits the *.dat files (the eperms, the users, the wperms, the requests).  After the workset checkout, Revit doesn't touch those files until you send the Workset back (or do another).  Those .dat files check out quickly via PW, get written, and get sent back.  

      With Element Borrowing, those files are always going all over the place, and it could get tricky.   In a large project, distributed or not, Worksets are the way to go, in my opinion.  I'm sure others may disagree, but I've never had an issue when I was working in Revit using Worksets.

      You probably already have the information in another format, but if you go to midamericacadd.org/2013-conference-presentations , you can download a presentation done at last year's Mid America CADD Community's conference here in Kansas City around ProjectWise and Revit, which includes some nice AVIs.

      HTH,

      Thanks,

      Shawn

      ------------

      • Cancel
      • Vote Up 0 Vote Down
      • Sign in to reply
      • Verify Answer
      • Cancel
    • Andrea Jackson
      0 Offline Andrea Jackson Wed, Apr 30 2014 4:38 PM

      We recently began using ProjectWise with Revit.  We have experienced a number of hiccups when using Central files.  I can not tell you how many times our central file was became corrupt and had to be recreated from local copies or older versions.  We have experienced quite a bit of lost work and lost time.

      • Cancel
      • Vote Up 0 Vote Down
      • Sign in to reply
      • Verify Answer
      • Cancel
    • Brendan McFarlane
      0 Offline Brendan McFarlane Tue, Mar 18 2014 9:08 PM in reply to Paul Patterson

      Thanks for the info Paul,

      Yes, I have read and digested the white paper, the BS1192 collaboration on the project is a client requirement, and as our core Revit team (Arch/Struct/MEP) is based in one location, the WAN latency issue won't be a problem. I'm also in favour of real-time collaboration, and will be monitoring the progress to see if we need to tweek the workflows to deliver the project more efficiently.

      Is there any impact on Revit file maintenance with using PW, and have you had any file corruption problems?

      Brendan

      • Cancel
      • Vote Up 0 Vote Down
      • Sign in to reply
      • Verify Answer
      • Cancel
    >

    Communities
    • Home
    • Getting Started
    • Community Central
    • Products
    • Support
    • Secure File Upload
    • Feedback
    Support and Services
    • Home
    • Product Support
    • Downloads
    • Subscription Services Portal
    Training and Learning
    • Home
    • About Bentley Institute
    • My Learning History
    • Reference Books
    Social Media
    •    LinkedIn
    •    Facebook
    •    Twitter
    •    YouTube
    •    RSS Feed
    •    Email

    © 2023 Bentley Systems, Incorporated  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy |  Terms of Use  |  Cookies