In RAM Concept, the end modeling of the Beam seem to affect the slab deflection and Punching design of the slab.When a Continuous beam is modeled to the center of the column it seems to be stiffer than when it is modeled to the sides of the columnThis difference is affecting significantly the Reactions at the column and the deflection at the slab.Refer to the attached word for the results and diagramsIn theory the stiffness should not be affected by the end of the beam since the column is very stiff compared to the beam.So what would be the most appropriate method to model the Beam-Column Connection and why is there a difference in the results.Thank you in Advance
In RAM Concept, columns are point objects. The program does not add a rigid area that is bounded by the width and depth of the column. The last paragraph under "Why does the load history deflection increase when the column depth is increased?" on the web page below discusses a technique for modeling rigid zones over columns if you wish to include this in your model. Adding a tool to automatically create rigid joints is Enhancement #125166 in our database.
http://communities.bentley.com/products/structural/structural_analysis___design/w/structural_analysis_and_design__wiki/18265.ram-concept-load-history-deflections-unexpected-behavior
Since columns support the slab at a single point, all beams should extend to the centerline of the column. If the beam is extended to the face of the column only, the slab area will be meshed over the column. Since the beam is stiffer than the slab, this will create a discontinuity in stiffness that will affect analysis results.
Answer Verified By: Carl Abinader
The statement is similar to the statements made on the RAM Structural System-RAM Concept wiki page below. You may find the statements on that page less confusing.
http://communities.bentley.com/products/structural/structural_analysis___design/w/structural_analysis_and_design__wiki/other-considerations-when-importing-into-ram-concept
The statement that the concrete beams should be modeled to the outside face of the supporting column means that the beam should extend past the interior column face over the center of the column and end at the opposite face (or outside face) of the column. In all cases, beams should at least extend to the centerline of the support.
Walls are line objects in RAM Concept. Beams that are supported by walls should extend to at least the centerline of the wall for similar reasons.