Hi,
We are migrating to Staad.Pro connect edition - Version 21.00.02.43. - Please find the images below.
1. While comparing the output of AISC ASD-10 and 16, a mistake in the slenderness check is observed in AISC ASD-16 (as marked red in below image).
2. Same model being used with only change in design code. Even the utilization ratios are different in many cases (as marked red in below image).
Kindly let me know the way forward.
Apart form the above, below listed errors exists which are listed as known issues in the forum. Please let me know whether these issues are resolved or not.
3. Utilization ratio is shown for only one member.
4. In member property tab - Missing tabs "Design Property" and "Steel Design"
5. No information available in the utilization ratio report - Design property, Actual ratio, allowable ratio, Claues, L/C are missing
Best Regards,
Vinod
Could you please upload the file?
Hi Abishek - Please find the data below.
STAAD SPACESTART JOB INFORMATIONJOB NAME xyzENGINEER NAME xyzENGINEER DATE xyzCHECKER NAME xyzAPPROVED NAME xyzEND JOB INFORMATIONUNIT MMS MTONJOINT COORDINATES1 11070 0 -4200; 2 11070 0 0; 3 5530 0 -4200; 4 5530 0 0; 5 0 0 -4200;6 0 0 0; 7 11070 8000 -4200; 8 11070 8000 0; 9 5530 8000 -4200;10 5530 8000 0; 11 0 8000 -4200; 12 0 8000 0; 13 8300 8000 -4200;14 8300 8000 0; 15 3160 8000 -4200; 16 3160 8000 0; 17 940 8000 -4200;18 940 8000 0;MEMBER INCIDENCES1 1 7; 2 2 8; 3 3 9; 4 4 10; 5 5 11; 6 6 12; 7 8 7; 8 10 9; 9 12 11;10 12 18; 11 10 14; 12 11 17; 13 9 13; 14 18 17; 15 18 16; 16 17 15;17 16 15; 18 16 10; 19 15 9; 20 14 13; 21 14 8; 22 13 7; 23 6 10;24 2 10; 25 5 9; 26 1 9; 27 12 5; 28 8 1; 29 4 9;START USER TABLETABLE 1WIDE FLANGEH200X200X8X126208 200 8 200 12 4.61049e+007 1.60075e+007 260437 1600 3200H400X200X8X138412 400 8 200 13 2.37e+008 1.74e+007 357000 3200 4333.33H350X175X7X116314 350 7 175 11 1.36e+008 9.84e+006 193000 2450 3208.33H200X200X8X12_46353 200 8 200 12 4.72e+007 1.6e+007 260000 1600 4000H250X125X6X93766 250 6 125 9 4.05e+007 2.94e+006 77500 1500 1875ENDMEMBER PROPERTY JAPANESE1 TO 6 UPTABLE 1 H200X200X8X12MEMBER PROPERTY JAPANESE10 12 15 TO 19 UPTABLE 1 H400X200X8X13MEMBER PROPERTY JAPANESE7 TO 9 11 13 20 TO 22 UPTABLE 1 H350X175X7X11MEMBER PROPERTY JAPANESE23 TO 29 UPTABLE 1 H200X200X8X12_4MEMBER PROPERTY JAPANESE14 UPTABLE 1 H250X125X6X9MEMBER TRUSS 23 TO 29MEMBER RELEASE14 START MY MZ14 END MY MZ17 START MY MZ17 END MY MZ20 START MY MZ20 END MY MZDEFINE MATERIAL STARTISOTROPIC SM490E 20.904POISSON 0.3DENSITY 7.85e-009ALPHA 1.2e-005DAMP 0.03TYPE STEELEND DEFINE MATERIALCONSTANTSMATERIAL SM490 ALLBETA 270 MEMB 1 TO 6BETA 90 MEMB 23 TO 29SUPPORTS1 TO 6 PINNEDCUT OFF MODE SHAPE 30LOAD 1 LOADTYPE Dead TITLE SLSELFWEIGHT Y -1.2 LOAD 2 LOADTYPE Dead TITLE EquipmentLOADMEMBER LOAD7 CON GY -9 21008 CON GY -9 210014 CON GY -2 125014 CON GY -2 295017 CON GY -2 125017 CON GY -9 210017 CON GY -2 295020 CON GY -9 2100LOAD COMB 101 "D"1 1.0 2 1.0 PERFORM ANALYSISLOAD LIST 101PARAMETER 1CODE AISC UNIFIED 2016METHOD ASDFYLD 0.0331408 ALLBEAM 1 ALLTRACK 2 ALLCHECK CODE ALLSTEEL MEMBER TAKE OFF ALLSTEEL TAKE OFF ALLPRINT ALLFINISH
Best Reagrds,
Dear User,
we have already noticed this bug and reported to the development team. It has already been fixed by them and will be available in next update i.e. update 3 which is expected to release in a month or 2.
Dear Abishek,
Thanks for your response!
Regards,