STADD PRO and RC Designer Concrete Design Issue

Hi All,

I am facing one issue regarding different result while doing beam design using STADD PRO v8i and RC Designer(Interactive).

Corresponding to Beam No 61(Member 7), I am getting huge difference is Ast of both the results, however moment value is almost same. Kindly help me to resolve this issue.

Also, Beam No 116 is passed in design by STAAD PRO but it failed in concrete design by RC Designer. Please help here also.

STAAD RESULT RC DESIGNER STAAD RESULT RC DESIGNER
Beam No L/C Mz kNm Mz kNm Area of Steel Area of Steel
61 COMBINATION LOAD CASE 3 71.183 71.2 1230 1608
-490.895 (SAGGING) -491 (SAGGING) 2570 3217

Also, please find attached model for your ease of working.

4532.Assembly Hall Project.std

Parents Reply Children
No Data