Dear sir,
Regarding Ductile design of RCC columns using RCDC, We have some questions as follows:
As per the relevant clauses of IS 13920 (2016), Two types of ‘Joint checks’ have been introduced. They are – 1)Relative Moment Strength at Joint, 2) Shear check at joint. RCDC checks for both in the ‘Column’ module. Thedetailed calculation report for the same is available separately as well as for each column.
1. Relative Moment Strength – In this check ‘Moment Capacity of Column’ is compared with ‘MomentCapacity of Beams’ framing into the same. For this check, RCDC reads end-forces of beams connectedto the columns. For the governing moment, it calculates Ast-required and details the top and bottomreinforcement. This reinforcement is further used to perform this check. The same method is beingused already for ‘Shear capacity check of columns’.
2. Joint Shear Check- In this check the shear demand at joint is calculated as per below fig,
As per the above, we confuse how to adjust the reinforcement of beams when beam-column joints failing.
Regards
Liyanan
As per the above questions, I build a one-story RCC frame, column size 450x450 pass, but if select Ductile design of columns, we need to increase column size upto 900x900 and set so many reinforcement. Based on our experience, we think it is not reasonable as per general practice. If beam-column joints failing, should be also adjust the reinforcement of beams to make Ductile design pass, but we can't find any menu in RCDC regarding Ductile design of RCC column.
Hope get your answer.
Answer Verified By: Li Yanan 李亚楠
Hello,
I would suggest to refer the below links to know how we are dealing with this joint check.
https://communities.bentley.com/products/ram-staad/w/structural_analysis_and_design__wiki/51946/is-13920-2016_5f00_joint-check_5f00_column-capacity-calculation_5f00_options-in-rcdc
The below link contains a validation for the same. You may need to login to download the document.
communities.bentley.com/.../indian-code---is-456--2000-is-13920-2016
Im worried about this phenomena
Upload the file here