Bentley Communities
Bentley Communities
  • Site
  • User
  • Site
  • Search
  • User
RAM | STAAD | ADINA
  • Product Communities
RAM | STAAD | ADINA
RAM | STAAD | ADINA Wiki Tension members being designed for compression
    • Sign In
    • -RAM | STAAD | ADINA Wiki
      • +ADINA
      • +iTwin Analytical Synchronizer_
      • +Structural Analysis Support Solutions
      • +RAM Concept
      • +RAM Connection
      • +RAM Elements
      • +RAM SBeam
      • +RAM Structural System
      • -STAAD.Pro
        • +Revision History
        • -STAAD.Pro Support Solutions
          • STAAD.Pro Safety Related Features
          • -Analytical Modeling workflow
            • +STAAD.Pro Analysis Solutions
            • -STAAD.Pro Design Solutions
              • +STAAD.Pro Aluminum Design
              • +STAAD.Pro Concrete Design
              • -STAAD.Pro General Design Solutions
                • Design codes supported by STAAD design code licenses
                • Tension members being designed for compression
                • What are the Design Codes supported by STAAD.Pro SS5?
              • +STAAD.Pro Steel Design
              • +STAAD.Pro Timber Design
            • +STAAD.Pro General Solutions
            • +STAAD.Pro Import/Export Solutions
            • +STAAD.Pro Modeling Solutions
          • +Building Planner workflow
          • +Connection Design workflow
          • +Physical Modeling workflow
          • +Piping workflow
          • +Postprocessing workflow
          • +Steel AutoDrafter workflow
        • +STAAD.Pro OpenSTAAD
        • +(+) Archived Wikis
        • +STAAD.Pro - Known Issues
        • +STAAD.Pro Download/Installation/Performance/Security
        • +STAAD.Pro Licensing Solutions
        • +STAAD.Pro Webinars/Videos/Events
      • +STAAD Foundation Advanced
      • +STAAD Advanced Concrete Design (RCDC)
      • +STAAD.building
      • +STAAD RCDC FE
      • +Scenario Services
      • +STAAD.offshore
      • +Limcon
      • +Microstran
      • +MStower
      • +Structural Dashboard
      • +Structural WorkSuite
    • +RAM | STAAD Learning Resources
    • Simplifications to Bentley's Engineering Simulation Software Licenses

     
     Questions about this article, topic, or product? Click here. 

    Tension members being designed for compression

    Applies To
    Product(s): STAAD.Pro
    Version(s): ALL
    Environment: ALL
    Area: Design Solutions
    Subarea: General Design Solutions
    Original Author: Sye Chakraborty, Bentley Technical Support Group

     

    I defined the braces as MEMBER TENSION but I see these failing in slenderness and the Kl/r limit that these are being checked against is the one corresponding to compression ( 200 ) and not the one corresponding to tension ( 300 ). Can you please explain why ?

     

    First of all please ensure that you are using REPEAT LOADs and NOT LOAD COMBINATIONs for combining the primary load cases when you are using a MEMBER TENSION ( or COMPRESSION ).

     

    If a tension-only member is vertical or sloping, the selfweight of the member will induce a varying axial force which will be zero at the top node and compressive at the bottom node. In combination cases where the selfweight load case is a component, this will cause the axial force to be tensile at the top and compressive at the bottom. In such cases, the nature of the force at the 2 ends cannot be used as a criteria to decide if the member is in tension or in compression. So, the program uses the sign of force at the mid-point of the member. But the fact remains that there will be some compression at the bottom node.

    If STAAD finds any hint of compression even at one end of a member, it lowers the slenderness limit to 200. So for these members, although these are specified as MEMBER TENSION, these may be reported as failed in slenderness when Kl/r > the allowable limit for compression. The slenderness check does not practically mean much as the axial force in the member is very small anyway. In such situations you may just bypass the slenderness check for such members by assigning the MAIN parameter and setting it to 1.

    • tension members failing in slenderness
    • Member Tension
    • compression force
    • compression
    • Share
    • History
    • More
    • Cancel
    • Sye Created by Bentley Colleague Sye
    • When: Wed, Feb 24 2016 4:42 PM
    • Modestas Last revision by Bentley Colleague Modestas
    • When: Wed, Apr 26 2023 10:51 AM
    • Revisions: 4
    • Comments: 0
    Recommended
    Related
    Communities
    • Home
    • Getting Started
    • Community Central
    • Products
    • Support
    • Secure File Upload
    • Feedback
    Support and Services
    • Home
    • Product Support
    • Downloads
    • Subscription Services Portal
    Training and Learning
    • Home
    • About Bentley Institute
    • My Learning History
    • Reference Books
    Social Media
    •    LinkedIn
    •    Facebook
    •    Twitter
    •    YouTube
    •    RSS Feed
    •    Email

    © 2023 Bentley Systems, Incorporated  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy |  Terms of Use  |  Cookies