Hello, perhaps a silly question but visually I don't see in ORD vertical profile design a difference between design of vertical curves using either parabola or circular curves, no matter how much I create exaggeration. They should appear slightly different as K value does not define radius. Any ideas?
Many thanks
Oleg
Oleg,
It's mostly true that there are no visual differences. One of the differences isn't in what you can see, but in how they behave in combination with other elements.In theory you can design a vertical loop using a circular curve, but when you use a parabolic curve that will never happen.
I suggest you do an internet search for the differences and why a parabola is the preferred curve type.
Jan
Thanks Jan, even if both the circular and parabolic curves are symmetrical, there are fundamental differences between the two. But to make sure I have made a consultation with both online academia and Chat GPT Wolfram engine - they both concur with my premise of a small difference that should be obvious in vertical alignment design.
I never claimed there are no differences, it's just that they aren't visible for the small section of the parabola that is displayed.
Took me a bit of time to confirm it but I think your assumption is not correct and differences between the two curves are significant, which I believe has a far reaching consequences... You can see image of comparison below. Happy to be corrected.
Which tool are you using to test? Profile Between Points shows a clear difference between the 2 curve types.
Regards,
Mark
OpenRoads Designer 2022 R3 (10.12) | Microstation 2023 | ProjectWise CE 3.4
Same with the Curve from Element tool